Lost and Found on Oak Island
Photography by Brenda Torrey
When a young boy went missing on a crowded Oak Island beach, an entire community sprang into action.
The Thursday before the Fourth of July was one of Oak Island’s busiest days of the year. Less than 24 hours after the community gathered for Oak Island’s annual Beach Day celebration, the island would find itself united by a different purpose.
Heat advisories were in effect. The beaches were packed shoulder to shoulder. Families crowded the sand near 46th Street, one of the island’s busiest areas, close to Middleton Park, the splash pad, the gazebo and the ballfields.
For Katy Bannerman, it was just another summer day at the beach with friends. Her family knew the island well. They purchased annual parking passes, and their two boys, Silas, 8, and Avery, 6, had been coming to Oak Island since they were just weeks old. The children had learned to swim almost as soon as they could walk.
As a longtime educator and the new assistant principal at West Brunswick High School, Bannerman was accustomed to organization, structure and responsibility.
Then, in a moment, everything changed.
As the group prepared to leave for the day, they realized Avery was missing.
Panic set in immediately. Bannerman began running along the shoreline, screaming her son’s name.

Contributed Photo
“Every minute was excruciating,” she says.
Text messages flew from her phone as friends, family members and church groups sprang into action. Members of her church, Crosswinds in Leland, began praying. Friends from Bible study spread the word, and people started calling everyone they knew on the island to go help.
News spread quickly. Local social media influencer Amanda Hofmann, aka WilmingtonMom, who happened to be on the beach near the Bannermans that day, shared a post calling the situation “every mom’s worst nightmare.” The post eventually reached more than 1,111,000 people across Facebook and Instagram and was widely shared on Oak Island local pages as the community rallied around the family.
At the same time, Oak Island’s rescue network was springing into action.
Oak Island Ocean Rescue Supervisor Eve Chrisman and her partner that day, Jayden Watkins, were the first to respond. Oak Island Ocean Rescue, which operates through the Oak Island Fire Department, coordinated with the volunteer, nonprofit Oak Island Water Rescue team. What Bannerman later described as an “all hands on deck” effort soon became a reality as crews mobilized on both land and water.
Beachgoers-turned-volunteers searched in every direction. Some walked the shoreline while others entered the water wearing goggles to search beneath the surface. Nearby homeowners reviewed security camera footage. Jet skis were deployed, and a systematic search was underway.

Contributed Photo
“It really seemed like a well-oiled machine,” Bannerman says.
Back at work, Bannerman’s husband, Corbin, who had not been at the beach that afternoon, could do little more than wait for updates and pray from his office at D.R. Horton as the search unfolded. Throughout the ordeal, rescuers kept Bannerman informed while helping her remain as calm as possible. Yet as the search continued, the panic began taking a physical toll. Every minute felt like an hour. Then, approximately 50 minutes after the 911 call was placed, the radio call finally came.
Avery had been found.
Confused and frightened, the determined little boy had walked miles looking for his mom among hundreds of colorful Shibumis lining the shore, all of which looked identical to his family’s.
At the time, Fire Chief Lee Price was overseeing the operation and called Deputy Fire Chief Chris Sillings and told him to grab another UTV and start searching. As he drove along the beach, Sillings stopped to speak with families while Avery’s photograph, name and description circulated among responders and beachgoers alike. Then came the breakthrough.
A woman walking with her own child had seen the posts circulating online and recognized Avery. She stayed with him until help arrived. Moments later, Sillings came upon them. And he brought the exhausted six-year-old back to his mother. Despite her own medical symptoms from the stress, Bannerman ran as soon as she saw the vehicle.
“He is a tough little boy,” Bannerman says. “He was trying so hard to hold it together and to find us. He must have been so exhausted. But when he saw me, we both broke down.”
For Sillings, the successful outcome reflected hours of preparation, training and teamwork.
Oak Island’s fire department has evolved far beyond traditional firefighting responsibilities.

“We’re an all-hazards fire department,” Sillings explains. “We handle car wrecks, medical calls, hazardous materials incidents and much more.”
Over the past several years, the department has significantly expanded its beach operations. Firefighters now help oversee beach patrols, rip current education, water rescues, drone operations and emergency response efforts along nearly ten miles of shoreline. The department hires seasonal personnel, such as Chrisman and Watkins, who work under the supervision of year-round staff members.
The town’s growing drone program has added another layer of protection, building upon the legacy of Shawn Berry, the town’s beloved first drone operator, who recently passed away.
Sillings was quick to downplay his own role.
“I didn’t do anything miraculous,” he says. “This was operational. It just happened to be me who rode by on the UTV.”
Even after Avery was safely reunited with his family, the work of the rescue crews was not finished. Another emergency call came in almost immediately.
Weeks later, Bannerman returned to the station with a meal for the rescuers.
“Even unloading the food, everybody was helping everybody else,” she says. “You could tell they were a team.”
During her visit, another call came in, and firefighters once again rushed into action.
Today, the Bannermans do a few things differently. Their boys now wear GPS watches whenever they visit the beach. (Bought that very evening after Avery’s long walk!)
The Town of Oak Island also uses the opportunity to remind visitors about the rescue stations located throughout the island. Supported by the Jack Helbig Memorial Foundation, the stations contain rescue tubes that can save lives in an emergency while also serving as important landmarks along the shoreline.
Officials encourage families to choose one of the stations as a designated meeting place and to pay close attention to the street numbers posted on the signs.
There is one more piece of advice many parents give their children: If you ever become separated from your family, look for another mother with children and ask for help. Never be afraid to shout for help.
Sillings offers one final piece of advice of his own.
“If a child goes missing, call immediately,” he says. “Just call. You can always back off later.”
Although the Bannermans hope they never experience anything like this again, they say they discovered something beautiful in the middle of one of the worst days of their lives.
They witnessed neighbors helping neighbors. They saw strangers stop to pray. They watched people drop everything to help a family they had never met. They saw years of training, preparation and teamwork put into action.
In the end, Avery’s story became more than the story of one frightened, lost little boy. It became the story of first responders prepared to answer calls for help, a community willing to help and thankfully a story with a happy ending.
Take the fear out of finding a loved one…
Supported by the Jack Helbig Memorial Foundation, the Town of Oak Island has installed rescue tube stations that can save lives in an emergency while also serving as important landmarks along the shoreline.
Know your location: The Town of Oak Island has Rescue Tube Stations on the beach side of every access. Before finding your perfect spot on the beach, make sure everyone in your family knows the street number displayed on your closest Rescue Tube Station, and make this your “meeting spot” if you get lost or separated.
Take a photo: When establishing your meeting spot, be sure to take a photo that clearly shows everyone in their attire and how they look that day. If a search is needed for anyone who is lost or separated, first responders will have an accurate photo to use when out looking.
Don’t rely on devices: Phones can be lost or damaged, and batteries can die, so don’t always assume you’ll be able to contact your family or use GPS to “find your way back.” Avoid trying to navigate using physical landmarks like the pier or unique houses, as it can be difficult to judge distances across an open beach strand. Instead, use the signage on the Rescue Tube Stations to know exactly where you are, and how to get to where you need to be.
Don’t be afraid to ask for help: If you’re an adult who can’t find your family, put the pride away for just a moment and ask one of our Beach Safety staff for assistance, or call 9-1-1.
Make sure Kids know WHO to ask for help: Beach Safety Division runs multiple patrols all day, in specially marked UTVs. Let them know it’s OK to yell, wave or do whatever they need to get our attention! We promise, they won’t get in trouble and shouldn’t feel embarrassed about getting lost.
You must be logged in to post a comment.